Personally my favorite game is Silent Hill 2. The story is beyond creepy. It's a game I still thnk about years after playing it. After Silent Hill 3 which wasn't bad I feel the people making the games really dropped the ball. Silent Hill 4 was terrible in my opinion, which is sad the original idea had a lot of potential, but I feel was poorly exiecueted. My biggest complaint about Silent Hill is even though I beyond love the creep factor. The controls are insanely difficult and now monsters respawn. Which in turn makes deaths feel cheap and further you feel forced to run through an environment you should want to explore. You aren't running because you are scared you are running because ammo is scarce and any second a monster will respond! Cheap death!